Do you think I should fix the clan stash function?

tramway

Do you think I should fix the clan stash function so that anyone will be able to donate to clan funds. Only the leader will be able to withdraw FG from stash.

But here are several concerns:

1. Do we really want the clan leader to be able to withdraw from stash anytime they want?
2. Should the transactions be anonymous to the clan, or should everyone in the clan be able to see the transaction logs
3.Suggestions?

DODGERFAN · Posted: 09 Feb 2008 05:54 pm Post subject:

i say you should and make it visible to only the clan members who donated and ya only the leader should be able to withdraw but the clan should know about it and what he did with it

clan members should vote on whether he can do it or not

xtreme_music · Posted: 09 Feb 2008 06:14 pm Post subject:

defintely a good idea it should be able to be accessed by leader and co-leader

tramway · Posted: 09 Feb 2008 07:39 pm Post subject:

so both the leader and co-leader will be able to withdraw ALL the clan funds anytime they want? Do u think it'll be an easy way to scam

DODGERFAN · Posted: 09 Feb 2008 07:40 pm Post subject:

ya but if you make it like i said they have to vote on if they take it out

tramway · Posted: 09 Feb 2008 07:45 pm Post subject:

thats a good idea, but how will members vote. And how to implement it into the code

DODGERFAN · Posted: 09 Feb 2008 07:55 pm Post subject:

i no nothing about codes but like in a clan you have to vote for promo it wil be the same thing

pitbulllvr76 · Posted: 09 Feb 2008 08:08 pm Post subject:

what if the clan stash could only be used as rewards among clan members...so the leader and co-leader are the only ones that can take out the fg but it can only be dispensed to the rest of the clan...then as a clan they can decide where the fg goes....whether it is transferred back to the stash or given out for rewards

pitbulllvr76 · Posted: 09 Feb 2008 08:16 pm Post subject:

or what if there was a max ammount that could be with drawn...then the stash couldn't be emptied completely...

DODGERFAN · Posted: 09 Feb 2008 08:42 pm Post subject:

for future reference you could just edit your topic andd add thats a double post like the idea tho

pitbulllvr76 · Posted: 09 Feb 2008 08:43 pm Post subject:

magikod · Posted: 09 Feb 2008 09:11 pm Post subject:

I think that it should have the leader's be the only one to notice that a member has donated to the guild. Also the leader and the co-leader (if permitted by the leader) to withdraw at any moment.

treezzzzz · Posted: 10 Feb 2008 08:49 pm Post subject:

i think you should make it so that only the leader can access the funds, but everyone in the clan should be able to see the clan's gold logs (who donated, what stuff was spent on, etc)
having to vote on funds would be really tedious and take too long, and also would defeat the point of having a clan leader.
also since the leader paid the fg to make the clan and it's also his clan it wouldnt make sense to have the other members restricting his rights. if he was abusing his power then people would just leave the clan, and also people wouldnt donate fg to the clan and/or even join it unless they liked and trusted the leader

pitbulllvr76 · Posted: 12 Feb 2008 12:57 pm Post subject:

I agree with treezzzzz....all valid points...if restrictions are made though I still think both the clan leader and co-leader should have access

Ryan[ProFreshENT] · Posted: 12 Feb 2008 02:10 pm Post subject:

treezzzzz · Posted: 12 Feb 2008 05:25 pm Post subject:

15 fg is nothing. personally i think restrictions are kinda stupid. like i said, if you dont trust your guild master why join his guild?

also it could be cool to have more ranks (like treasurer for example that can help manage funds and stuff).

pitbulllvr76 · Posted: 13 Feb 2008 08:50 pm Post subject:

xtreme_music · Posted: 14 Feb 2008 07:37 pm Post subject:

pitbulllvr76 · Posted: 16 Feb 2008 04:44 pm Post subject:

If there is way to add an automatic notification, then there wouldn't need to be a restriction on who takes out the fg...everyone in the clan would know when and how much was taken and for what...

gary6729 · Posted: 28 Feb 2008 07:17 am Post subject:

if you make it like i said they have to vote